Employment law for employers in Birmingham and the Midlands.

Advice for employers only. A workplace complaint or dismissal needs a process and a written record. If you want to agree an employee's departure, a settlement agreement records the terms and settles their claims against you. If an employee brings a claim instead, an employment tribunal hears the dispute. We can prepare the response and represent you there.

What does an employment tribunal examine after a dismissal?: Employing people

An employment tribunal hears disputes between workers and employers. When examining a dismissal, it considers whether the decision was within the range of responses a reasonable employer could have taken. It also considers whether you followed a fair procedure.

The written record shows how you reached the decision. Investigation notes, invitation letters and appeal records matter. A fair decision can be difficult to defend if you have not recorded the process.

The Employment Rights Act 2025 is changing these rules in stages. From 1 January 2027 the period an employee must have worked before claiming ordinary unfair dismissal is expected to fall from two years to six months. The limit on compensation for that claim is also expected to be removed. Employers who have relied on the two-year period need to review their procedures before that date.

Where it goes wrong: Employing people

  1. Does paying an employee settle their claims?

    A settlement agreement must meet conditions in law to be binding. These include advice to the employee from a named independent adviser who is insured. An informal payment agreed through WhatsApp does not settle their statutory claims. The employee can receive the payment and still bring a claim.

  2. Not recording the workplace procedure

    Failure without good reason to follow the ACAS Code of Practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures allows a tribunal to increase an award by up to 25 per cent. Record the events and decisions when they happen. Later notes cannot replace a record made at the time.

  3. A conversation that can still be used as evidence

    Section 111A of the Employment Rights Act 1996 can prevent a conversation about ending employment being used as evidence, but only in an ordinary unfair dismissal claim. It does not protect the conversation in a discrimination claim, an automatic unfair dismissal claim or where there has been improper behaviour. Do not assume every discussion about leaving is protected.

Inside an employment contract

Illustrative extract

  1. 01 / Notice period

    The employer and employee must give the notice required by this agreement, subject to any applicable statutory minimum.

  2. 02 / Restrictive covenants

    After employment ends, the employee must observe the restrictions described here on specified activities and business contacts.

  3. 03 / Probation

    The employee's work will be reviewed during probation, with any extension and notice arrangements recorded in writing.

  4. 04 / Place of work

    The normal place of work and any agreed arrangements for home working or work at other locations are recorded here.

Note 1 / 4

This sets the notice each side must give to end employment. Statutory minimum requirements also need to be considered.

Where it often goes wrong

The contract and the statutory requirements are treated as if they were the same thing.

Note 2 / 4

These clauses seek to limit particular activities after departure. Their scope and enforceability depend on the wording and circumstances.

Where it often goes wrong

A restriction covers more activity, time or territory than the business interest it seeks to protect.

Note 3 / 4

Probation is an agreed review period at the start of employment. It does not remove statutory employment rights.

Where it often goes wrong

Probation is treated as a period without employment rights, or its end passes without the agreed review.

Note 4 / 4

This identifies where work is normally done. Any flexibility to change location should be read alongside the agreed working arrangements.

Where it often goes wrong

The written location and the actual arrangements differ, leaving expectations about attendance unclear.

1 / 4
Talk to us about your document

Employing people

Employing people services

Settlement agreements

A settlement agreement ends the employment, or a dispute, on agreed terms and prevents the employee bringing the claims it lists. It is binding only if it meets the statutory conditions, including independent advice to the employee from a named adviser who is insured. Employers usually pay a contribution towards that advice.

Contracts

A worker is entitled to a written statement of terms from the first day. Restrictions on later work, called restrictive covenants, must go no further than is reasonable to protect a legitimate business interest.

  • Senior or executive service agreement
  • Director's service agreement
  • Zero hours or casual worker contract
  • Apprenticeship agreement
  • Contractor or consultancy agreement with status advice
  • Recruitment pack: offer letter, right to work, references
  • Confidentiality and garden leave letters

Policies and handbooks

Policies can be evidence in a claim. A disciplinary policy sets a standard against which the employer's procedure can be measured.

  • Single HR policy, each
  • Family leave policy suite
  • Staff privacy notice and data protection policy
  • HR document audit
  • Employment status audit
  • IR35 status determination and contract review

Disciplinary, grievance and absence

A tribunal reads the invitation letter, evidence and meeting notes. These records need to show the process followed.

  • Grievance process support, per matter
  • Performance management plan and letters
  • Long-term sickness and capability process
  • Reasonable adjustments advice
  • Flexible working request response
  • Maternity, paternity and shared parental leave advice

Redundancy and change

The number of proposed redundancies and their timing determine collective consultation obligations. The award for failure to consult, called a protective award, doubled to 180 days in April 2026.

  • Redundancy, one employee
  • Redundancy, 2 to 19 employees
  • Changing terms and restructuring advice
  • TUPE advice: measures letters and employee liability information
  • Restrictive covenant enforcement letter

Employment tribunal

The time limit for bringing most employment tribunal claims extended from three months to six months on 1 October 2026.

  • Pre-claim correspondence and protected conversations
  • Case management agenda and list of issues
  • Preliminary hearing, representation
  • Disclosure list and hearing bundle
  • Witness statements
  • Judicial mediation, preparation and attendance
  • Final hearing preparation and brief to counsel
  • Legal consultant attendance at the final hearing, per day
  • Full defence to a one day final hearing
  • Full defence of a medium complexity claim, 2 to 3 days
  • Post-hearing advice, reconsideration and costs
  • Prospects of an EAT appeal and notice of appeal

Worth knowing: Employing people

  • £30,000 the amount of a termination payment that can usually be paid free of income tax under a settlement agreement. Pay for notice is taxed in full
  • 25 per cent the maximum uplift to an award for unreasonable failure to follow the ACAS Code
  • 1 October 2026 the tribunal time limit for most claims extended from three months to six
  • 30 October 2026 the sexual harassment duty rises to taking all reasonable steps, with liability for third party harassment
  • 1 January 2027 the unfair dismissal qualifying period is expected to fall from two years to six months, and the compensatory award cap to be removed
  • 180 days the protective award for failure to consult on collective redundancy, doubled in April 2026
  • Day one statutory sick pay has been payable from the first day of absence since April 2026

If you are not sure what any of this means: Employing people

An employment tribunal hears a claim by a worker against an employer and examines the evidence and procedure. Its response form, called ET3, records your defence and the reasons you dispute the claim. The tribunal reads documents such as investigation records, meeting notes and witness statements. A settlement agreement is a written agreement under which an employee gives up claims in return for a payment, and it binds the employee only if they have had independent legal advice on it. If you are not sure what any of this is called, describe it in your own words and we will work out what it is.

Check your employment documents

Not sure which of these you need?

A first consultation will tell you what the work involves and what it costs.