What is unfair dismissal?
An employee who is dismissed can claim unfair dismissal at an employment tribunal. The tribunal is a judicial body that hears disputes between employers and workers. It asks two questions. Did the employer have a fair reason? Did the employer act reasonably in dismissing for that reason, including following a fair procedure?
Until 31 December 2026 an employee needs two years' service to bring an ordinary unfair dismissal claim. Where the dismissal takes effect on or after 1 January 2027, the qualifying period falls to six months under the Employment Rights Act 2025. Some claims, such as dismissal for whistleblowing, pregnancy or asserting a statutory right, need no qualifying service at all, and neither does a discrimination claim.
What are the five fair reasons?
Section 98 of the Employment Rights Act 1996 lists them. Capability or qualifications, which covers poor performance and ill health. Conduct, meaning misconduct. Redundancy. A statutory restriction, such as a driver losing their licence. And some other substantial reason, which covers situations such as a breakdown in working relationships or a refusal to accept a necessary change in terms.
The employer must show which reason applied. Dismissing for one reason and later relying on another is a common way to lose a claim.
What does acting reasonably mean?
The tribunal does not ask what it would have done. It asks whether dismissal was within the range of responses a reasonable employer could have taken. Two reasonable employers can reach different decisions on the same facts. What the tribunal will not accept is a decision no reasonable employer would have made, or a decision reached without a fair process.
The size and resources of the business are taken into account. A small employer is not expected to have a human resources department. It is expected to investigate, to tell the employee the case against them, to listen, and to record what happened.
What procedure should I follow?
For conduct and performance, the Acas Code of Practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures applies. Investigate first. Write to the employee setting out the allegation, the evidence and the possible outcome, and invite them to a meeting with enough notice to prepare. Tell them they may bring a colleague or trade union representative. Hold the meeting, consider what they say, and decide. Confirm the decision in writing with the reasons and offer an appeal heard by someone not involved before.
A tribunal that finds an employer unreasonably failed to follow the Code can increase compensation by up to 25 per cent. The Code is dated 2015. Acas consulted on an updated version between July and September 2026, and the new Code had not been published as at November 2026.
For ill health, the process is consultation with the employee, medical evidence, consideration of adjustments and alternative roles, and a decision only when it is clear the employee cannot return within a reasonable time. For redundancy, the process is warning, consultation, fair selection and a search for alternative work.
Can I dismiss without notice?
Only for gross misconduct, meaning conduct so serious that it destroys the employment relationship, such as theft, violence or serious breach of safety rules. Even then the procedure must be followed. Dismissing on the spot without investigation or a hearing is usually unfair, however serious the allegation. Suspension on full pay while investigating is the usual course.
What does an unfair dismissal cost?
A tribunal can award a basic award, calculated like statutory redundancy pay, and a compensatory award for lost earnings. For dismissals taking effect on or after 6 April 2026 the compensatory award is capped at £123,543 or 52 weeks' pay, whichever is lower. The cap is removed for dismissals on or after 1 January 2027. Discrimination awards have never been capped.
Compensation is reduced if the employee contributed to the dismissal, or if a fair procedure would have led to the same result. It is increased by up to 25 per cent for failing to follow the Acas Code.
What to do next
Identify the reason for the proposed dismissal and match it to the list above. Check the employee's start date against the qualifying period that will apply on the date the dismissal takes effect. Follow the procedure for that reason and keep a record of each step. A review before the first letter is sent is the point at which most problems can still be avoided.