Charity or community interest company?

Two ways to run a business for the public good, with different rules on control, pay and tax.

For social enterprises3 minute read

What is the difference?

A charity exists only for charitable purposes for the public benefit and is regulated by the Charity Commission. A community interest company, known as a CIC, is a company that carries on a business for the benefit of the community and is regulated by the Office of the Regulator of Community Interest Companies at Companies House.

A CIC cannot be a charity. The Companies (Audit, Investigations and Community Enterprise) Act 2004 says so, even where the CIC's purposes would otherwise be charitable. The choice is one or the other.

Who controls it and can they be paid?

A charity is run by trustees who are usually unpaid and who cannot normally be employed by the charity. The founder of a charity does not own it and can be removed under the governing document.

A CIC is run by directors who can be paid reasonable salaries and who can also own the shares, if it has shares. A founder who wants to run the organisation as a paid job and keep control usually prefers a CIC.

What can be done with the money?

A charity's money can be spent only on its purposes. Nothing can be paid to members or founders beyond authorised payments for goods and services.

A CIC has an asset lock, which means its assets must be used for the community and, on closure, pass to another asset-locked body. A CIC limited by shares can pay dividends to shareholders, but no more than 35 per cent of distributable profits in total. A CIC limited by guarantee pays no dividends.

What are the tax differences?

A charity recognised by HMRC pays no corporation tax on most income applied to its purposes, can claim Gift Aid of 25p for every £1 donated by a UK taxpayer, and receives mandatory 80 per cent relief from business rates on premises used for charitable purposes. Many grant funders fund only charities.

A CIC pays corporation tax on its profits like any company, cannot claim Gift Aid, and has no automatic rates relief. It can receive grants, but fewer funders support CICs, and donors receive no tax relief.

How is each set up?

A CIC is registered at Companies House with its articles, a community interest statement on form CIC36 and an online fee of £115. Each year it files accounts, a confirmation statement and a community interest report on form CIC34. The Regulator must approve the community interest test.

A charity is set up as a CIO, charitable company, trust or association and registered with the Charity Commission, with no registration fee. It then files an annual return and, above £25,000 income, accounts. Both structures must meet Companies House identity verification rules where they are companies.

Which should I choose?

Choose a charity if the purposes are charitable, the organisation will depend on donations and grants, and the founders are willing to hand control to a board of trustees and not be paid for running it.

Choose a CIC if the organisation will earn most of its income from trading, the founders want to be paid employees or directors with control, or the purposes benefit the community but are not strictly charitable, such as a community cafe or a training business.

Can I have both?

Some organisations run a charity for the charitable work and a separate trading company, which may be a CIC, for commercial activity. The trading company donates its profits to the charity. This separates the risk of the business from the charity's assets. It also means two sets of accounts and two boards.

What to do next

Write down where the money will come from, who will run the organisation day to day and whether they expect to be paid, and whether the purposes fit the charitable descriptions. Those answers decide the structure. The incorporation or registration documents can then be prepared.

Shaheen Legal is not regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority. Your work is carried out by Kashif Sajjad, a solicitor of England and Wales, SRA number 7250349, who is personally regulated by the SRA. Check this on the SRA register